Skip to main content

A fishing flycatcher

Given the oddity of this post's title, and the strange behavior documented below, one might be excused for thinking this to be an April Fool's Day prank. Especially since it is indeed April 1st, and because your narrator is in large part Irish, and we of the Emerald Isle are known for our love of prankery.

But a childish prank this is not. The inimitable Chuck Slusarczyk, Jr., captured the following amazing series of images at Wendy Park in Cleveland. Chuck's images show an Eastern Phoebe dive-bombing into Lake Erie and snaring an (apparent) emerald shiner, Notropis atherinoides. SIDEBAR: Don't come back as an emerald shiner in Lake Erie, or if you must, STAY AWAY from the surface, for Poseidon's sake! Everyone, even adventurous songbirds, wants to eat you!

While a number of general bird-related websites casually make mention that phoebes will take small fish, the actual concrete evidence seems rather sparse. The scientific literature does not seem to teem with documentation. There is a mention of fishing phoebes in a 1926 account in the former journal Bird-Lore. A more robust accounting of this behavior can be found in a 1957 edition of the Auk (74:264-265), in a paper entitled "Eastern Phoebe fishing" by the legendary Laurence C. Binford, who was once a major player in California birding and an ornithological tour de force.

In his paper, Binford describes two phoebes capturing minnows along Lake Michigan at Chicago on the date of - no kidding - April 1st, 1956. Binford and his fellow observer noted the birds capturing a total of seven "small, silvery fish" (also very likely emerald shiners). His description of how the phoebes snared and ate these fish is remarkably similar to the sequence shown in Chuck's photos that follow.

The phoebe is our toughest flycatcher. They're early to return, late to linger, and will often attempt to tough it out in northern winters.This hardiness is in large part due to their adaptability. The favored food are insects in the order Hymenoptera (bees and wasps - told you they're tough!), but no insect is safe near a phoebe. Push comes to shove, and they'll tackle odd fare such as ticks, spiders, and millipedes. And fish...

 Photo: Chuck Slusarczyk, Jr.

Our piscivorous phoebe scans the waters from a withered stalk of Canada goldenrod, Solidago canadensis.

Photo: Chuck Slusarczyk, Jr.

Its interest piqued, the phoebe drops down to a ledge on the cement pier, the better to get a bead on the unsuspecting shiners.

 Photo: Chuck Slusarczyk, Jr.

Ah! A target in the sights, the phoebe dive-bombs toward the water.

Photo: Chuck Slusarczyk, Jr.

Success! An emerald shiner is pulled from the depths and taken to a convenient ledge for consumption.

Photo: Chuck Slusarczyk, Jr.

A bit of shaking and tossing, and the flycatcher has the fish turned around and ready for swallowing, headfirst. Somehow the phoebe knows to ingest the shiner headfirst, just as all veteran fish-eaters such as Osprey do. Try this in reverse, and the scales are likely to catch in your throat.

Photo: Chuck Slusarczyk, Jr.

The phoebe holds its prize. This photo probably should have preceded the one above, but I'm feeling too lazy to switch them around. The hapless shiner looks a bit goggly-eyed shocked, but they always look that way, phoebe or not.

Photo: Chuck Slusarczyk, Jr.

Down the gullet it goes. A bit of sushi can't be bad for the phoebe - certainly more protein there than a beakful of midges.

Kudos to Chuck for expertly photo-documenting this behavior, and sharing his images with us. Who knows, come back in a couple hundred thousand years and there might be phoebe-kingfishers stalking our waters.

Comments

molly said…
Hello Jim,

I happened on your blog, researching "giant clams olentangy" tonight! Apologies for the off-topic inquiry, but I was delighted to find your space, and thought you might be able to answer my question: My kids (6 and 9) and I were at Highbanks, this afternoon, and my 9 y.o. son picked up a "giant" clam, from the water. We were surprised and tickled to find it alive! We're native Seattlites, in Ohio 5 years, and fairly sure this is no geoduck :) However, it's the first time we've found any clam close to this size--at least 6 inches long, 3-4" across, and 2-3" thick--in Columbus, Olentangy or otherwise. I wonder if you could help us identify it?
Thanks!
Molly

PS: We own and love your Great Lakes Nature Guide! Bought it when we first landed in Ohio.
Fabulous photos. I had no idea Phoebes would eat fish.

Popular posts from this blog

The Pinching Beetle, a rather brutish looking bug

The world is awash in beetles, and they come in all shapes and sizes. Few of them can match the intimidation factor of a Pinching Beetle, Lucanus capreolus, though. Those formidable looking mandibles look like they could slice off a finger.

Today was one of those coolly diverse days. I started off down in Fayette County, visiting the farm of a friend. He has restored about 25 acres of wetlands, and the response by the animal community has been nothing short of phenomenal. Blizzards of dragonflies of many species, amphibians galore, and nesting Blue-winged Teal, Pied-billed Grebe, and Sora. Among MANY other things. And all in a short two years. Add water and they will come.

Then, working my way home, I ducked into a Madison County cemetery that has a thriving population of Thirteen-lined Ground Squirrels, and shot images of our native prairie dog. Then, I stopped at a spot along Little Darby Creek, waded on in, and procured some pretty nice shots of various stream bluets and dancers. …

Calliope Hummingbird in central Ohio!

A hatch-year male Calliope Hummingbird strikes a pose. Small but tough, the hummingbird was feeding actively yesterday in 39 F temperatures. It frequents feeders and gardens at a home in Delaware County, Ohio, about a half-hour north of Columbus.

Fortunately, the wayward hummer appeared at the home of Tania and Corey Perry. Tania is a birder, and knew right away that the hummingbird was something special. For a while, the identification was up in the air, which isn't surprising. The Calliope Hummingbird used to be placed in its own genus, Stellula, but has recently been submerged into the genus Selasphorus, which includes Allen's, Broad-tailed, and Rufous hummingbirds. The latter two, especially, are quite similar to the Calliope in subadult plumage. Rufous is the default "vagrant" hummingbird here, with dozens of records and birds turning up annually. There is but one Ohio record of Allen's Hummingbird, from late fall/early winter 2009. Ditto the Calliope Hummi…

Ballooning spiders

Fear not, ye arachnophobes. The subject of this entry is indeed about spiders, but the star of the show is about as cute as a spider can get. And you'll want to know what we're about to learn...

On my recent West Virginia foray, we were strolling down a seldom-used lane, when a bright yellow object caught our eye. It was a goldenrod crab spider, Misumena vatia, on top of a post! Not only that, she - it is a girl - was acting extraordinarily goofy. The spider would stilt up as high as she could go on her legs, weave back and forth, jig side to side, and otherwise engage in what appeared to be spider break-dancing.

Click the pic for expansion, and you can see two columns of silk issuing from her spinnerets. This is an important point, as we set about determining what this non-web-making spider is doing.


So fixated was our spider on her task that she even rejected what would seem to me to be a perfectly scrumptious meal. This little caterpillar climbed rapidly up the post and dire…